Question:
Glad yours went well, Songbird. I didn’t like the risk of dying thing, but if I feel confident in the doc, I’d have no problem going for the biopsy. It sounds sensible to me. My liver’s been hurting for 30 years. Surely it’s not well, and I’d like to find out what’s up. It’s good to hear a "nice" biopsy story. Keith On Wed, 19 Nov 2003 15:39:56 GMT, Songbird <songbir…@netscape.net> wrote: – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->Hi, Mike, >I had some fears going in for the biopsy. My clinic does trials and >research and sticks to certain protocols, including a liver biopsy >before treatment. I was told I must do it. It measures the amount of >fibrosis, if any, that is present. I asked my hepatologist what the >risks are. Being a blunt kind of guy, he said something like "You could >die, worst case scenario." The risk is the same for this procedure as >any other. About 1-2%? risk of dying. My clinic has surgical teams >that do this procedure. I was not given meds before the procedure. If >they asked me to hold my breath I don’t remember. After the procedure I >could ask for pain meds, and did. I had to lie there for a few hours to >make sure nothing was bleeding/no complications. I’m glad I’m at this >teaching/research clinic! They know what they are doing. ps the pain >was mild. >Songbird >Michael Don Henry wrote: >> My Doc didn’t do one either. He told me it really didn’t matter in the whole >> scheme of things (my words) and that I could whether to do it or not. I >> chose not, mainly because we are so broke … not to mention the horrer >> stories,. >> — >> Peace, Mike
Response:
Well, there’s that too. Keith On Wed, 19 Nov 2003 08:14:26 -0600, "Michael Don Henry" – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -<mdhenryREMOVEC…@ev1.net> wrote: >I figure my liver looks like swiss cheese any way. I don’t want to see it.
Response:
Good luck to you too, Eileen. Thanks for writing. Keith On 19 Nov 2003 18:50:16 GMT, pizzane…@aol.com (Pizzaneene) wrote: – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->>Hey all. Is it weird that my doc’s not doing a biopsy before starting >>treatment? >Keith, >Get one if you can. It is still the Gold Standard for disease progression. > My first biopsy didn’t go as well as I was told it would, but this is the only >way to measure actual damage done to the liver. >It was my choice to forgo treatment the first time, and now the option is not >available because of my kidney disease. >I am overdue for my 5 year follow up but I am gonna know my liver disease >progression when I get it. And this time, I am going to be pre medicated and >with a competent Radiologist whom I trust. >Good Luck Keith, let us know what or how you do. >eileen
Response:
Good decision!!!!! — Regards, Shawn . "Keith" <rea…@mostly.com> wrote in message
news:85qnrv4pqcnmeav13l3u9ghfemqc81ralr@4ax.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> CHEZ > It helped. Everyone’s remarks did. From echoes I got in email from > people in the newsgroup, I decided I do need a new doctor. My > brother’s an internal medicine/gastro-enterology guy but he won’t > treat family. He’s recommended a really young doctor he knows who’s > had some good results. I put my IFN on hold, canceled my doctor > forever, and I’ve got an appontment with the new guy Monday. > Thanks to all, > Keith > On Wed, 19 Nov 2003 14:08:39 GMT, "CHEZ" <s…@nospam.com> wrote: > >Well if you have a doc that knows what he is doing,
complications should be > >avoided. Liver Biopsy will confirm HCV and also range of liver damage. For > >myself, I would want to know how bad of shape my liver was in. Truthfully > >they really can’t tell by blood work alone. > >I had 2 Biopsies with no complications at I.U. Medical Center in > >Indianapolis. They perform a lot of them there and they know what they are > >doing. I would have one if I were you, but do some
research on what hospital – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> >is best for treating HCV infection and liver problems in general. > >Hope this helps Keith. > >"Keith" <rea…@mostly.com> wrote in message > >news:k0flrvsrn57s80qo85v2qlua8oskblnt3d@4ax.com… > >> Hey all. Is it weird that my doc’s not doing a biopsy before starting > >> treatment? > >> Some of you mentioned the horrors of their biopsies. And my friend who > >> had 1a had an awful biopsy. They missed and put a hole in his gall > >> bladder, and sent him home with it leaking. He got really sick and > >> ended up in the hospital for a while. When I asked him if it’s weird > >> to skip the biopsy, he said, "better you never have one." It’s no > >> wonder that’s his opinion. > >> Wwhat do you guys think? > >> Keith
Response:
Good luck with your new BCLD!!!! — Russ Tanner Palmer, Alaska email: russattannersacredotcom http://www.tannersacre.com "Keith" <rea…@mostly.com> wrote in message
news:85qnrv4pqcnmeav13l3u9ghfemqc81ralr@4ax.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> CHEZ > It helped. Everyone’s remarks did. From echoes I got in email from > people in the newsgroup, I decided I do need a new doctor. My > brother’s an internal medicine/gastro-enterology guy but he won’t > treat family. He’s recommended a really young doctor he knows who’s > had some good results. I put my IFN on hold, canceled my doctor > forever, and I’ve got an appontment with the new guy Monday. > Thanks to all, > Keith > On Wed, 19 Nov 2003 14:08:39 GMT, "CHEZ" <s…@nospam.com> wrote: > >Well if you have a doc that knows what he is doing, complications should be > >avoided. Liver Biopsy will confirm HCV and also range of liver damage. For > >myself, I would want to know how bad of shape my liver was in. Truthfully > >they really can’t tell by blood work alone. > >I had 2 Biopsies with no complications at I.U. Medical Center in > >Indianapolis. They perform a lot of them there and they know what they are > >doing. I would have one if I were you, but do some research on what hospital > >is best for treating HCV infection and liver problems in general. > >Hope this helps Keith. > >"Keith" <rea…@mostly.com> wrote in message > >news:k0flrvsrn57s80qo85v2qlua8oskblnt3d@4ax.com… > >> Hey all. Is it weird that my doc’s not doing a biopsy before starting > >> treatment? > >> Some of you mentioned the horrors of their biopsies. And my friend who > >> had 1a had an awful biopsy. They missed and put a hole in his gall > >> bladder, and sent him home with it leaking. He got really sick and > >> ended up in the hospital for a while. When I asked him if it’s weird > >> to skip the biopsy, he said, "better you never have one." It’s no > >> wonder that’s his opinion. > >> Wwhat do you guys think? > >> Keith
Response:
In article <HPKub.22897$kL2.5…@fe3.columbus.rr.com> "CHEZ" <s…@nospam.com> writes: >I had 2 Biopsies with no complications at I.U. Medical Center in >Indianapolis.
I’ve had one liver biopsy at Kaiser Permanente in Fremont, CA. It was a directed biopsy, using ultrasound. No complications. Went to work after lying on gurney for two hours following biopsy. Of course, I don’t do anything physical at work, else I would have stayed home. I was given Versed, I think, and there was good music playing in the room where they performed the bx, and my doctor was wearing overalls and a flannel shirt! (She was cute, too.) -Pete Zakel (p…@seeheader.nospam) "I like the future, I’m in it."
Response:
That is where I had mine Pete, with no complications as well. Chez "Pete nospam Zakel" <px…@cadence.com> wrote in message news:3fce7583$1@news.cadence.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> In article <HPKub.22897$kL2.5…@fe3.columbus.rr.com> "CHEZ" <s…@nospam.com> writes: > >I had 2 Biopsies with no complications at I.U. Medical Center in > >Indianapolis. > I’ve had one liver biopsy at Kaiser Permanente in Fremont, CA. It was a > directed biopsy, using ultrasound. No complications. Went to work after > lying on gurney for two hours following biopsy. Of course, I don’t do > anything physical at work, else I would have stayed home. > I was given Versed, I think, and there was good music playing in the room > where they performed the bx, and my doctor was wearing overalls and a flannel > shirt! (She was cute, too.) > -Pete Zakel > (p…@seeheader.nospam) > "I like the future, I’m in it."
Response:
CHEZ It helped. Everyone’s remarks did. From echoes I got in email from people in the newsgroup, I decided I do need a new doctor. My brother’s an internal medicine/gastro-enterology guy but he won’t treat family. He’s recommended a really young doctor he knows who’s had some good results. I put my IFN on hold, canceled my doctor forever, and I’ve got an appontment with the new guy Monday. Thanks to all, Keith – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -On Wed, 19 Nov 2003 14:08:39 GMT, "CHEZ" <s…@nospam.com> wrote: >Well if you have a doc that knows what he is doing, complications should be >avoided. Liver Biopsy will confirm HCV and also range of liver damage. For >myself, I would want to know how bad of shape my liver was in. Truthfully >they really can’t tell by blood work alone. >I had 2 Biopsies with no complications at I.U. Medical Center in >Indianapolis. They perform a lot of them there and they know what they are >doing. I would have one if I were you, but do some research on what hospital >is best for treating HCV infection and liver problems in general. >Hope this helps Keith. >"Keith" <rea…@mostly.com> wrote in message >news:k0flrvsrn57s80qo85v2qlua8oskblnt3d@4ax.com… >> Hey all. Is it weird that my doc’s not doing a biopsy before starting >> treatment? >> Some of you mentioned the horrors of their biopsies. And my friend who >> had 1a had an awful biopsy. They missed and put a hole in his gall >> bladder, and sent him home with it leaking. He got really sick and >> ended up in the hospital for a while. When I asked him if it’s weird >> to skip the biopsy, he said, "better you never have one." It’s no >> wonder that’s his opinion. >> Wwhat do you guys think? >> Keith
Response:
>Hey all. Is it weird that my doc’s not doing a biopsy before starting >treatment?
Keith, Get one if you can. It is still the Gold Standard for disease progression. My first biopsy didn’t go as well as I was told it would, but this is the only way to measure actual damage done to the liver. It was my choice to forgo treatment the first time, and now the option is not available because of my kidney disease. I am overdue for my 5 year follow up but I am gonna know my liver disease progression when I get it. And this time, I am going to be pre medicated and with a competent Radiologist whom I trust. Good Luck Keith, let us know what or how you do. eileen
Response:
Hi, Mike, I had some fears going in for the biopsy. My clinic does trials and research and sticks to certain protocols, including a liver biopsy before treatment. I was told I must do it. It measures the amount of fibrosis, if any, that is present. I asked my hepatologist what the risks are. Being a blunt kind of guy, he said something like "You could die, worst case scenario." The risk is the same for this procedure as any other. About 1-2%? risk of dying. My clinic has surgical teams that do this procedure. I was not given meds before the procedure. If they asked me to hold my breath I don’t remember. After the procedure I could ask for pain meds, and did. I had to lie there for a few hours to make sure nothing was bleeding/no complications. I’m glad I’m at this teaching/research clinic! They know what they are doing. ps the pain was mild. Songbird – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Michael Don Henry wrote: > My Doc didn’t do one either. He told me it really didn’t matter in the whole > scheme of things (my words) and that I could whether to do it or not. I > chose not, mainly because we are so broke … not to mention the horrer > stories,. > — > Peace, Mike
Response:
My Doc didn’t do one either. He told me it really didn’t matter in the whole scheme of things (my words) and that I could whether to do it or not. I chose not, mainly because we are so broke … not to mention the horrer stories,. — Peace, Mike Keith <rea…@mostly.com> wrote in message
news:k0flrvsrn57s80qo85v2qlua8oskblnt3d@4ax.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Hey all. Is it weird that my doc’s not doing a biopsy before starting > treatment? > Some of you mentioned the horrors of their biopsies. And my friend who > had 1a had an awful biopsy. They missed and put a hole in his gall > bladder, and sent him home with it leaking. He got really sick and > ended up in the hospital for a while. When I asked him if it’s weird > to skip the biopsy, he said, "better you never have one." It’s no > wonder that’s his opinion. > Wwhat do you guys think? > Keith
Response:
I figure my liver looks like swiss cheese any way. I don’t want to see it. — Peace, Mike Dwight <Dwi…@Me.net> wrote in message
news:Mszub.30882$pG5.8322@newssvr31.news.prodigy.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Keith, my last bx was ten years ago. I had three of them in about 2 > years time. The worst part of the first two, after the first few > minutes, was having to stay in the hospital overnight to check for > bleeding. It doesn’t sound like they are doing this anymore from what > I’ve heard here. My last one was done laporoscopically (please excuse > my spelling on that one). I would rather have gone through one of the > traditional bx’s, but I did get a full color picture of my liver. If I > had seen it in a meat counter I would have called the health departement. > Dwight > Keith wrote: > > Hey all. Is it weird that my doc’s not doing a biopsy before starting > > treatment? > > Some of you mentioned the horrors of their biopsies. And my friend who > > had 1a had an awful biopsy. They missed and put a hole in his gall > > bladder, and sent him home with it leaking. He got really sick and > > ended up in the hospital for a while. When I asked him if it’s weird > > to skip the biopsy, he said, "better you never have one." It’s no > > wonder that’s his opinion. > > Wwhat do you guys think? > > Keith
Response:
Well if you have a doc that knows what he is doing, complications should be avoided. Liver Biopsy will confirm HCV and also range of liver damage. For myself, I would want to know how bad of shape my liver was in. Truthfully they really can’t tell by blood work alone. I had 2 Biopsies with no complications at I.U. Medical Center in Indianapolis. They perform a lot of them there and they know what they are doing. I would have one if I were you, but do some research on what hospital is best for treating HCV infection and liver problems in general. Hope this helps Keith. "Keith" <rea…@mostly.com> wrote in message
news:k0flrvsrn57s80qo85v2qlua8oskblnt3d@4ax.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Hey all. Is it weird that my doc’s not doing a biopsy before starting > treatment? > Some of you mentioned the horrors of their biopsies. And my friend who > had 1a had an awful biopsy. They missed and put a hole in his gall > bladder, and sent him home with it leaking. He got really sick and > ended up in the hospital for a while. When I asked him if it’s weird > to skip the biopsy, he said, "better you never have one." It’s no > wonder that’s his opinion. > Wwhat do you guys think? > Keith
Response:
My hats off to all of you guys in the soup. Damn! It makes my little whatever you call it, a walk in the park. Y’all are the best. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Shawn wrote: > Mine was a nightmare! I’m going to have to have a second one > just to keep my insurance going. This time I’m going to > demand some pretty strong drugs in case they miss again!!!!
Response:
Hey all. Is it weird that my doc’s not doing a biopsy before starting treatment? Some of you mentioned the horrors of their biopsies. And my friend who had 1a had an awful biopsy. They missed and put a hole in his gall bladder, and sent him home with it leaking. He got really sick and ended up in the hospital for a while. When I asked him if it’s weird to skip the biopsy, he said, "better you never have one." It’s no wonder that’s his opinion. Wwhat do you guys think? Keith
Response:
Keith, my last bx was ten years ago. I had three of them in about 2 years time. The worst part of the first two, after the first few minutes, was having to stay in the hospital overnight to check for bleeding. It doesn’t sound like they are doing this anymore from what I’ve heard here. My last one was done laporoscopically (please excuse my spelling on that one). I would rather have gone through one of the traditional bx’s, but I did get a full color picture of my liver. If I had seen it in a meat counter I would have called the health departement. Dwight – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Keith wrote: > Hey all. Is it weird that my doc’s not doing a biopsy before starting > treatment? > Some of you mentioned the horrors of their biopsies. And my friend who > had 1a had an awful biopsy. They missed and put a hole in his gall > bladder, and sent him home with it leaking. He got really sick and > ended up in the hospital for a while. When I asked him if it’s weird > to skip the biopsy, he said, "better you never have one." It’s no > wonder that’s his opinion. > Wwhat do you guys think? > Keith
Response:
Mine was a nightmare! I’m going to have to have a second one just to keep my insurance going. This time I’m going to demand some pretty strong drugs in case they miss again!!!! — Regards, Shawn . "Keith" <rea…@mostly.com> wrote in message
news:k0flrvsrn57s80qo85v2qlua8oskblnt3d@4ax.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Hey all. Is it weird that my doc’s not doing a biopsy before starting > treatment? > Some of you mentioned the horrors of their biopsies. And my friend who > had 1a had an awful biopsy. They missed and put a hole in his gall > bladder, and sent him home with it leaking. He got really sick and > ended up in the hospital for a while. When I asked him if it’s weird > to skip the biopsy, he said, "better you never have one." It’s no > wonder that’s his opinion. > Wwhat do you guys think? > Keith
Posted in